Yahoo answers who was julius caesar9/12/2023 ![]() Both are continually on the move, finally arriving at a capital city: Rome and Jerusalem.Both meet a patron/rival: Pompey and John the Baptist, and their first followers: Antony and Curio, and Peter and Andrew.Both have to cross a fateful river: the Rubicon and the Jordan.Both Caesar and Jesus begin their careers in northern countries beginning with G: Gallia and Galilee.Carotta's astonishing ( astonishingly trivial) similarities. Readers can make up their own minds, as I list each of Sig. Signor Carotta claims that "new ground is being broken". Carotta's springboard "to place Caesar's history and the Gospel ( sic, presumably Mark's Gospel) side by side and see if further resemblances ( sic) occur". His conclusion, that Caesar's statues "not only looked like a pietà, but the inscription on the base also evoked the Christ", is patently ridiculous: none of the statues survive, so it is only Signor Carotta's opinion that they would have resembled a Renaissance pietà ( don't you require a Virgin Mary to make a pietà, in any case?), and none of the inscriptions (some two dozen are known, I believe) "evoke the Christ". PM, and the Christian Chi-Rho symbol) and (2) that PM looks a little like the Chi-Rho if you invert the letters! Frankly, this sounds a little desperate. Undeterred, - indeed, oblivious to his blunder - Signor Carotta continues with supplementary claims: (1) that Christos resembles pontifex maximus because both can be abbreviated to two letters (i.e. pontifex maximus, consul et dictator), and only a single inscription is known to name him as archiereus megistos (probably because the megistos element is tautological: archiereus already means pontifex maximus without the addition of the Greek adjective megistos = maximus). pontifex maximus, consul) or archierea hypaton kai diktatora (i.e. Unfortunately for Signor Carotta, the overwhelming majority of Caesar's inscriptions name him as archierea kai autokratora (the equivalent of pontifex maximus et imperator) or archierea hypaton (i.e. Then, although he does not (cannot?) cite any source that actually calls Julius Caesar " chrêstos" (if Signor Carotta knows of any, why does he not cite them?), he claims that it "looks like a contraction of archiereus megistos", by missing out several letters.Ĭlearly, this foundation of his theory depends entirely upon Julius Caesar holding the title archiereus megistos, so that it can first be contracted (why?) into chrêstos, and then misconstrued as Christos, "Christ". As proof, he first claims that inscriptions of Julius Caesar name him as archiereus megistos, which he interprets as the Greek equivalent of pontifex maximus (Caesar's official religious title as "high priest"). Signor Carotta's entire theory springs from one unfortunate misconception: the claim that Julius Caesar was known as chrêstos ("worthy"), a word that could have been misconstrued (he argues) as Christos, "Christ". Here, readers may amuse themselves by deciding for themselves: "Was Jesus Caesar?" His publicity breathlessly announces: " Carotta's new evidence leads to such an overwhelming amount of similarities between the biography of Caesar and the story of Jesus that coincidence can be ruled out." However, so trivial and contrived are these alleged similarities that it is no wonder that no serious reviews have ever appeared, and no recognized authority, whether theologian, historian or philosopher, has yet engaged with Signor Carotta. Signor Carotta's theory seems to be that the Gospel of Saint Mark is a coded retelling of Caesar's life, in which the character of Jesus represents the divine Julius himself. (Oddly, in the original Continental versions, the title is phrased as a question: " War Jesus Caesar?" or " Jésus, est-il Divus Julius?") ![]() It seems that, for several years now, the left-wing Italian philosopher and ancient history aficionado Francesco Carotta has been promoting his bizarre theory that Jesus was Caesar. It has been several months since I linked the names of Jesus Christ and Julius Caesar ( here) but, in the meantime, I have come across a much more sensational connection between these two people. It is a new year, and high time we had a book review.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |